|
3/4
|
Star Wars: The Force Awakens
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Maybe the new sequels and spin-offs can be more adventurous, but The Force Awakens had me smiling, reminiscing, and critiquing all at the same time: It hits all the marks, without any real surprises.
Posted Dec 18, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Dangerous Men
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
With every new minute, there's another head-scratching choice that's bound to elicit some amazing out-loud responses, so this feels like a true party flick.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Beasts of No Nation
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
It focuses on one child's unique experience. It's not an issue film - it's a story about a boy who has a rich family life but then tragically loses it all and is left to fend for himself.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
Brooklyn
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
From a dramatic standpoint, the film's biggest asset is also its biggest challenge: Brooklyn eschews showy conflict in favor of small character moments and a leisurely pace
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
1/4
|
The Hunger Games: Mockingjay, Part 2
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
I understand that YA books succeed by transposing real teen concerns into life-and-death fantasy situations, but any connection to the characters that existed by the end of 2013's Catching Fire has been stripped away by these plodding Mockingjay movies.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
99 Homes
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
A breathless thriller with expertly shot "you are there" camerawork and a rising score, but it also comes from moments of conflict that are pitched at a very high level. Emotions are high, lives are at stake, and something is very, very wrong.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2/4
|
Spectre
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Most of the film plays like a game of Connect Four, piling up and grouping together characters and schemes from Craig's last three films in vaguely related ways, in the hopes that the connections to Bond's past will bring them some emotional heft.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
1.5/4
|
Our Brand Is Crisis
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Instead of a black comedy about powerful U.S.-government employed parasites pulling dirty tricks on foreign soil, we get a silly revenge story about two rivals who are supposed to be really smart - something we rarely see.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Steve Jobs
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Plays fast and loose with the facts, but so did Shakespeare's "Julius Caesar." I'm not comparing Sorkin's prose with the Bard's, but using a widely known culturally important figure as a way into telling stories with universal themes is, well, universal.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Eraserhead
(1977)
|
Eric Melin
|
Linear plots with easily defined cause and effect are the kinds of stories we are used to, but sometimes it's refreshing to enter a world where logic takes a backseat to purely evocative storytelling.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
5/5
|
Mulholland Dr.
(2001)
|
Eric Melin
|
Because Lynch is playing with archetypes like the wide-eyed innocent, he's able to subvert them with a heightened reality that suckers us in.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Goodnight Mommy
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Franz and Fiala's clever script doles out context in small, strategic doses, and keeps the audience guessing, even as the strange behavior on both sides increases and becomes more squirm-inducing.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Bridge of Spies
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
For the most part, "Bridge of Spies" is a sober reflection on America actually living its values and living up to its promise.
Posted Dec 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2/4
|
The Walk
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Zemeckis jettisons most of the hard edges of Petit's character in favor of a wide-eyed follow-your-dreams story. Rendered in broad strokes, it falls more into the fairy tale category than anything else.
Posted Dec 11, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
Sicario
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
There's not much emotional investment in any of the characters, and the film has little to add to any serious discussion of its subject matter - but as a pitch-black thriller, Sicario succeeds with style.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
The Martian
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
If there's one fault to find in this inspiring tale, it's that Damon's just too smart and self-effacing to be real. But to say that would be too cynical: a trait this film is hiding away in the same cupboard, thankfully, with all of the schmaltz.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Sleeping With Other People
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Leslye Headland has a knack for taking familiar rom-com situations and injecting into them a hardcore dose of truth. Truth can be uncomfortable, but as this movie illustrates, it can be riotously exhilarating as well.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
The Look of Silence
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Not as formally exciting as The Act of Killing but because it's so singularly focused, it's a more emotionally engaging story. And because its concerns are different, both films together are a richer experience and provide a more complete picture.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Mission: Impossible - Rogue Nation
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
With the will-they-or-won't-they tension, the densely plotted conflicts that rarely give you time to think, and the fact that everyone on all sides has a reason to stop Hunt, this is a satisfying Hollywood actioner that keeps you guessing.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/5
|
Terminator Genisys
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
It's only when the funny callbacks, clever change-ups, and suspenseful action scenes pause for a moment that the wooden performances of its leads Emilia Clarke and Jai Courtney become a weakness.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
Inside Out
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
A brilliantly visualized concept anchors Inside Out in a way that ensures it will resonate for years to come. Kudos to Pixar for again reminding us that animated entertainment can appeal to all ages and speak to universal truths.
Posted Oct 07, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
1.5/4
|
Jurassic World
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Commentary on how audiences always want "bigger" over "better" is not enough. It's window dressing. You still have little kids in danger of being eaten by dinosaurs run amok and a guy who thinks he's the Dinosaur Whisperer.
Posted Jun 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
Love & Mercy
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
This has to be the best-sounding movie ever made, and like Brian Wilson himself, it's full of naked emotion, while still retaining an air of mystery.
Posted Jun 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/5
|
The Merchant of Four Seasons
(1971)
|
Eric Melin
|
Fassbinder is going for realism, but almost a heightened, stagey version of it. This strategy makes the film more deeply felt, amplifying the awkwardness.
Posted Jun 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
Magician: The Astonishing Life and Work of Orson Welles
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
"Magician" is a brisk documentary that dismantles many Welles myths, some of them by the great man himself - as he tells the same story three different ways in different interviews.
Posted Jun 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
The Silence of the Sea
(1949)
|
Eric Melin
|
Although the movie's narrative and acting style are typical of older films, "Le Silence de la Mer" has a modern sensibility and feel, embracing subtlety and ambiguity in a way that was idiosyncratic at the time.
Posted Jun 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
Limelight
(1952)
|
Eric Melin
|
It was Chaplin's last great film, and it showcases not just a love for the performing arts (she's a ballerina, he's a vaudevillian), but also Chaplin's effortless sentimentality.
Posted Jun 13, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2/4
|
Tomorrowland
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
When Bird's movie clicks, it's easy to believe that human intelligence and ingenuity can overcome impending global disaster. That's why he should have given his audience more credit and not spelled everything out for them.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Avengers: Age of Ultron
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
Like Greek gods before them, superheroes are our modern myths, so why shouldn't they examine issues of the classic texts in our time? The end credit sequence actually gives this idea a visual corollary, as it shows a giant Hellenistic statue.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
White God
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
When it's all said and done, "White God" delivers an indictment of both sides, and its one that, despite its canine (anti-?)heroes, rings with an undeniable sadness and human truth.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Wild Tales
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
I hope that Quentin Tarantino, whose obsession with revenge pictures has started to reveal kinks in his armor, has seen "Wild Tales." While it embraces elements of the spaghetti western as Tarantino's films do, it also finds new ways to explore them.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2.5/4
|
The Wrecking Crew
(2008)
|
Eric Melin
|
From a narrative standpoint, "The Wrecking Crew" is scattered, which limits its appeal to pop music aficionados. As one of those people, I enjoyed the film despite its lack of forward movement.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
Ex Machina
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Garland's film sexualizes Ava to an embarrassing degree, which also is its entire point. His aim is to have his cake and eat it too, with images of female nudity literally created for the male gaze, subverted, and mined for maximum uncomfortability.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
Secretary
(2002)
|
Eric Melin
|
Shainberg sets up a restless quality in both characters, and he takes them very seriously but it still comes as a bit of shock to see what is normally considered to be sexist behavior finally and ultimately embraced.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
Furious 7
(2015)
|
Eric Melin
|
The actors are completely secondary. The hoops they jump through to get to the next action scene are just that. The expositional dialogue [starts] only after the action scene has, because they know we don't care why they're there: We're already with them.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
It Follows
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
The only control the teenagers have in the situation is to pass on the curse - and increase their sexual guilt tenfold. It's a brilliantly clean metaphor, not just for sexual nervousness, but also the transience of youth.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
What We Do in the Shadows
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
The film has all the low-key charm of a Christopher Guest movie, but it also has the dynamic kick of seamlessly blending its faux-cinma vrit style with the supernatural.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2.5/4
|
Gone Doggy Gone
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
A funny, low-budget indie that's at its best when it diverts from what is purported to be the main plot. It proves that Brown and Walter are talented comedic writers who aren't afraid to get more than a little absurd for a laugh.
Posted Jun 12, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
The Bitter Tears of Petra von Kant
(1972)
|
Eric Melin
|
On one level, it is an engrossing character study about changing power dynamics in relationships. On another, it's simply a marvel of fluid, focused filmmaking - where everything in the frame is loaded with meaning.
Posted Feb 28, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3.5/4
|
The Palm Beach Story
(1942)
|
Eric Melin
|
It's about as breezy, carefree, and anarchic as romantic comedies get. Full of absurd comedic digressions and bookends that still don't quite make sense, this eccentric road trip comedy would likely never get made in today's Hollywood climate.
Posted Feb 28, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2/4
|
American Sniper
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Too often in "Sniper," Eastwood kowtows to our basic need to have clear-cut good guys and bad guys. And when Kyle makes the impossible shot, it feels (in the limited context of the film) like we've actually won something. We haven't.
Posted Feb 28, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Foxcatcher
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Miller has a keen eye for examining the intersection of class, money and ambition. The screenplay compresses the timeline, moves key scenes around, and favors character over action, but it absolutely stays focused on these difficult larger themes.
Posted Feb 28, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
2/4
|
Inherent Vice
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Anderson is too enamored with his terrific ensemble cast. Perhaps 2 hours 20 minutes were needed for the plot to make any kind of sense, but there still feels like a lot of dead weight, and he is unable to infuse it with the energy of his other films.
Posted Feb 28, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
3/4
|
The Interview
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
It is indeed a lowbrow comedy, but it's not just some dumb movie - and the fictitious assassination of a living world leader is not even the most dangerous thing about it.
Posted Jan 03, 2015
Edit critic review
|
|
1.5/4
|
Top Five
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
When it feels loose and lived-in, it starts clicking into place. But when it pushes its characters toward unearned saccharine, it feels as fake as the industry it's supposed to be satirizing.
Posted Dec 31, 2014
Edit critic review
|
|
2/4
|
The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
The sad irony is that - given the enormous familiarity with Jackson's cinematic Middle-earth and the almost identical structure and conflict of both trilogies - the sixth and final film is a slog of an exercise; one of stubborn inevitability.
Posted Dec 31, 2014
Edit critic review
|
|
3/5
|
Death Metal Angola
(2012)
|
Eric Melin
|
... more than a treatise on the origins of this bombastic musical style. It's a story of hope. There's no reinvention of the form here, just a solid documentary on a subject you had probably never thought existed.
Posted Nov 22, 2014
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Interstellar
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
Despite some awkward pacing, easy sentimentality, and pandering it's still hard to resist. It's not just Nolan's ambition that should be admired. He actually pulls off scene after scene of unforgettable drama in colossal scale, both in space and on Earth.
Posted Nov 22, 2014
Edit critic review
|
|
4/5
|
Love Is Strange
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
It has plenty of conflict, but is virtually free from the demands of traditional plot-heavy films. It carries the ring of truth at least partially because its subtext is everything, and its scenes are rarely about what they're really about.
Posted Nov 22, 2014
Edit critic review
|
|
2.5/4
|
My Old Lady
(2014)
|
Eric Melin
|
My Old Lady doesn't break any new ground and sometimes feels too much like a play, but its actors help smooth over some of its more predictable patches with their estimable charm.
Posted Oct 17, 2014
Edit critic review
|