The Stepfather

Audience Reviews

View More

J H @UpstateNYThriller 6d 7.7 / 10 Great thriller movie, Mystery Murderer Stepdad with no name, kills family then moves on Penn Badgley is in it. Late 2000s movie. Killer thriller type movie, takes place in Oregon. See more Stoner J @Stoner Jul 15 Sure it ain’t the original, but it’s a solid remake that’s very entertaining, and far underrated. See more Victor D @Loyal_998 Jul 13 Im gonna write that this movie is boring and not interested to be re-watchable. Nothing about this was a good story to end like that. See more The W @TheWagners Jul 4 Again with these terrible remakes, a movie that doesn't take anything seriously. You'll wonder why there are no kills or there's no thrilling things happening. The effects are so bad as well. Terrible movie See more Ralph R @RT14837316 Aug 3 The Stepfather remake is a horror flick with a clean suburban sheen but it kinda feels like it was checked off a list rather than crafted. Direction and production look fine, the visuals are sharp, but there’s zero bite. Dylan Walsh is solidly creepy as quietly obsessive David, so credit there. Penn Badgley does okay as the suspicious teen, but the script keeps tripping him up with unbelievable choices. The rest of the cast? Sela Ward brings realism, And Amber Heard..... Story-wise, the setup is the only thing that grabs you; once the pattern kicks in, it gets predictable real quick. By the time you hit the ending, you’re like “yep”. See more TheMovieSearch R @TheMovieSearch 07/22/2025 The Stepfather (2009), starring Dylan Walsh, Sela Ward, Penn Badgley, and Amber Heard, is a remake of the 1987 classic that received mixed reviews upon release. While it doesn’t completely escape the shadow of its predecessor, it offers enough tension, suspense, and eerie moments to make it worth a watch. This isn’t a film trying to redefine the psychological thriller — instead, it delivers on familiar territory with enough competence to hold an audience’s attention. Dylan Walsh gives a chilling performance as the titular “stepfather,” perfectly balancing charm and menace. His portrayal of the seemingly all-American father figure hiding dark secrets is convincing, providing the film with its core tension. Sela Ward complements him with warmth and emotional grounding, giving the family dynamic a sense of realism amidst the creeping unease. Their interactions help the story feel anchored, even when the plot leans into familiar thriller clichés. Penn Badgley shines as the perceptive teenager who begins to suspect that something is off. Long before You, you can already see the intensity and natural screen presence he brings to the role, making his character compelling and adding layers to the suspense. Amber Heard delivers a solid performance as well, holding her own in the ensemble and portraying the concerned family member with authenticity. Her role isn’t flashy, but it contributes to the emotional weight and stakes of the story. The screenplay has its issues. It leans heavily on predictable beats and thriller tropes, occasionally making the tension feel forced or formulaic. Some character decisions can feel contrived, and the pacing drifts in places, leaving certain scenes less impactful than they could have been. Yet, despite these flaws, the movie does succeed in creating a lingering sense of unease. It keeps the audience guessing just enough and maintains a level of suspense that makes it suitable for a late-night viewing. The cinematography and direction work to amplify the claustrophobic, domestic tension. Close-ups, dimly lit interiors, and careful framing help convey the sense that something sinister is always lurking just beneath the surface. While it may not reach the iconic status of the original, it effectively utilizes visual storytelling to heighten the psychological tension and keep viewers invested. The Stepfather is not a masterpiece, and it certainly won’t redefine the thriller genre. But it has moments of genuine suspense, strong performances from a capable cast, and a story that, while familiar, remains engaging. For fans of domestic thrillers or anyone looking for a tense, eerie movie night, it delivers enough to satisfy, even with its shortcomings. See more Read all reviews

The Stepfather

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING